The Curated Self: Who We Are Online vs. Who We Are Alone

Michelle Labine

May, 2025

There’s a strange kind of split that happens in the age of constant connection.

The version of ourselves we share online is often real—but it’s rarely the whole story.
It’s curated. Thought through. Framed. Cropped.

We share what we’ve made peace with.
We share the things we’ve already processed.
We share the light once we’ve found our way through the tunnel.

But we don’t always show the mess.
The in-between.
The fragile, unfiltered moments that don’t have a tidy caption yet.

We’re not lying. We’re just selecting.
And selection is a form of survival.

It feels good to be seen in our strength.
It feels risky to be seen in our doubt.
So we polish the edges, even when we’re honest.

And the tricky part?
We compare ourselves to other people’s curated selves while carrying the full weight of our own behind-the-scenes life.

That’s the part no one talks about enough:
The cost of being both visible and unseen.
The pressure to show up when you don’t feel like you’re fully here.
The dissonance of performing closeness in a space that doesn’t always hold nuance.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with social media. It connects us. It informs. It inspires.
But it also distorts.
And if you’re not careful, it can leave you feeling like you’re never quite enough—not in your work, your body, your relationships, or your grief.

So if you’re tired of performing wellness while struggling quietly—let that be okay.
If you’re holding something heavy behind the camera—you're not alone.
If you’re scrolling through other people’s highlight reels while wondering why you feel so far behind—breathe.

You’re not behind.
You’re just real.
And your full, uncurated self is worthy of care, whether or not it fits into a square.

“People who are hurting don’t need avoiders, protectors, or fixers.
What we need are patient, loving witnesses.
People who sit quietly and hold space for us.
People to stand in the helpless vigil to our pain.”
Glennon Doyle

Everyone is Welcome